Gary Anderson’s Verdict: Littler’s a “Freak” Talent, But Humphries Rules the World – “He’s Not Consistent Enough Yet”

Gary “The Flying Scotsman” Anderson, the two-time PDC World Champion and one of darts’ most respected veterans, has sparked debate with his latest take ahead of the 2025 Mr Vegas Grand Slam of Darts. Speaking on the Weekly Dartscast on October 31, Anderson declared that Luke Littler isn’t the world’s best player right now — instead naming Luke Humphries as the current global No. 1, while reserving the title of “Europe’s best” for Michael van Gerwen.

At 53, Anderson has witnessed every modern great from Phil Taylor to Van Gerwen, and his blunt assessment has set social media ablaze. “Littler’s a freak… he’ll win everything soon,” he said, “but he’s not consistent enough to be called the best. Humphries is.”

Fans immediately split into camps online — some praising Anderson’s emphasis on longevity and consistency, others pointing out Littler’s record-breaking 2025 season.

Why Littler Falls Short: Anderson’s Breakdown

Anderson’s main argument is consistency. Littler’s rise has been astonishing — a world title, Grand Prix crown, Premier League triumph, and over £1.5 million earned in 2025 alone, all before turning 19. But Anderson highlights the lapses: his quarterfinal defeat to James Wade at the European Championship (10–7), a Players Championship 34 loss to Matt Campbell, and the off-stage registration blunder in Wigan.

“Littler’s a freak. He’ll win everything soon. But right now? He’s not consistent enough to be called the best. Humphries is,” Anderson repeated on air.

When asked to name the top players globally, his answer was clear:

“Who’s the best player in the world right now? That’s easy — Luke Humphries. But if you’re talking Europe? That’s still Michael van Gerwen. Simple.”

Humphries, Van Gerwen, Littler – Anderson’s Rankings

Humphries, known as “Cool Hand Luke,” has been the world No. 1 since January 2024. His calm, clinical style and ability to deliver under pressure — including Grand Slam and Matchplay titles — earned Anderson’s respect. “Luke’s got that cool head now,” he said. “He doesn’t miss when it matters.”

Van Gerwen, despite a quieter year by his own standards, remains dominant on European soil, claiming the Poland Masters, four Players Championships, and the Baltic Sea Open. “He’s still the king of Europe — when he turns up, everyone knows it,” Anderson added.

Littler’s talent, meanwhile, is beyond question. His averages and explosive scoring make him the sport’s biggest draw, but Anderson insists his consistency must still mature. He echoed his 2023 warning to the media: “Let the boy play darts… don’t overhype him.”

The Bigger Picture: A Three-Way Battle Ahead

Anderson’s verdict adds extra spice to the upcoming Grand Slam (November 8–16, Wolverhampton, £650,000 prize fund).

• Humphries (Group B vs. Damon Heta) will aim to bounce back after Euro heartbreak.
• Littler (Group A vs. Ryan Searle) can silence critics with another deep run and a shot at the £250,000 winner’s prize.
• Van Gerwen (Group C vs. Martijn Kleermaker) defends European pride and could clash with Humphries in the quarterfinals.

Anderson’s comments aren’t criticism — they’re tough love from a player who’s seen greatness up close. The Scotsman himself has trimmed two stone this season to extend his own career and continues to back Littler’s potential. “He’s fantastic,” he said. “But you need five years of what Taylor or MVG did before you’re in GOAT talk.”

Littler’s response came swiftly on Instagram: “Gary’s right — Humphries is class. But consistency? Watch Grand Slam.”

As Wolverhampton approaches, Anderson’s words hang over the oche like a challenge. The teenager’s time will come, but for now, as the veteran says — the throne belongs to Humphries. 🎯