Brooks Nader, the 28-year-old Sports Illustrated swimsuit model and star of the Hulu reality series *Love Thy Nader*, has responded to the swirling rumors that she was dating both tennis superstars Carlos Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner simultaneously during the 2025 US Open. In a recent appearance on *Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen* on September 17, 2025, Nader maintained an air of mystery, neither confirming nor denying the sensational claims while laughing off the speculation. Her coy demeanor has only fueled the intrigue surrounding the alleged love triangle, which reportedly unfolded amid the high-stakes drama of Flushing Meadows, where Alcaraz defeated Sinner 6-2, 3-6, 6-1, 6-4 in the men’s final to claim his second US Open title.
The Rumors: A Tennis Rivalry Goes Off-Court
The speculation ignited when Nader was spotted courtside at the US Open on August 31, 2025, cheering for Alcaraz during his third-round match against Arthur Rinderknech, seated alongside Stephen Colbert and his wife, Evelyn. Her presence sparked initial links to Sinner, after her sister Grace Ann Nader teased on the *Page Six Radio* podcast that Brooks was receiving messages from athletes, specifically one whose name “rhymes with winner.” This led fans to speculate about the Italian world No. 2, who had been the tournament’s top seed at the time.
Nader addressed the Sinner rumors on *Jimmy Kimmel Live!* on September 2, playfully dodging host Jimmy Kimmel’s questions: “Is this, like, an interrogation? I’m so scared right now!” When shown a photo of her at the US Open, she quipped, “Well, ask Stephen what match we were at. I don’t think [Sinner] was playing in that one. You’re close. You’re warm.” She clarified that she was at Alcaraz’s match, shifting the focus.
The plot thickened on September 10 at the Raising Cane’s New York Fashion Week show, where Grace Ann confirmed to *E! News* that Brooks is dating Alcaraz: “The rumors are true. Dating is such a loose term, but I do know he’s the man of the hour.” She added that Alcaraz, 22, has met two of her sisters, Mary Holland and Sarah Jane, but not her yet, calling him “such a cutie.”
However, a *Page Six* report on September 11 escalated the drama, claiming sources revealed Nader was “dating both” Alcaraz and Sinner during the tournament, evoking comparisons to the 2024 film *Challengers*. Nader was reportedly present for Alcaraz’s semifinal and final, cheering as he dethroned Sinner to reclaim the world No. 1 ranking.
Nader’s Response: “I’m So Scared Right Now!”
During her *Watch What Happens Live* appearance, host Andy Cohen directly confronted Nader about the dual-dating rumors. “Is there any truth to the rumors that you dated Spanish star Alcaraz and Italy’s Sinner?” Cohen asked. Nader, laughing nervously, replied, “Is this, like, an interrogation? I’m so scared right now!” She maintained an evasive tone, neither confirming nor denying the claims, and pivoted to her excitement for her reality show. When pressed further, she teased, “All I’ll say is, tennis is exciting—on and off the court.”
Nader’s playful yet non-committal response has left the door open for more speculation. Her sisters’ podcast comments about her “roster” of suitors in “country club sports” and Grace Ann’s hints have kept the story alive. Nader’s dating history—married to Billy Haire from 2019 to 2022, briefly linked to Prince Constantine-Alexios of Greece and Denmark in 2024, and dated *Dancing with the Stars* pro Gleb Savchenko until April 2025—adds to the intrigue.
Alcaraz and Sinner’s Silence
Neither Alcaraz nor Sinner has addressed the rumors. Alcaraz, who has been single since July 2024 when he told *The Sunday Times*, “It can be difficult as a tennis player to meet the right person because you are travelling all the time,” is focusing on recovery ahead of the Laver Cup (September 19-21, 2025). Sinner, rumored to be dating Danish model Laila Hasanovic, has remained quiet, preparing for the China Open (September 24-30).
Fans on X have been divided, with some joking about the “Challengers” parallels: “Brooks Nader dating both finalists? Tennis’s real plot twist!” (@TheTennisLetter). Others defended her privacy: “Let Brooks live—rumors are just that” (@SportsGossip).
A Mystery That Lingers
Brooks Nader’s evasive response to the rumors of dating both Carlos Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner has kept the tennis world’s off-court drama alive. While Grace Ann’s confirmation points to Alcaraz as her current interest, Nader’s playful deflection ensures the speculation endures. As Alcaraz and Sinner continue their rivalry on the court, Nader’s role in the story remains a captivating subplot in tennis’s glamorous narrative.
