Tennis legend snubs Coco Gauff, picks Jessica Pegula as America’s true No. 1: Here’s reason why
Tennis Legend Overlooks Coco Gauff, Declares Jessica Pegula as America’s Top Player
A heated debate has ignited in American tennis circles after a renowned analyst bypassed Coco Gauff—reigning US Open champion and 2024 WTA Finals winner—to anoint Jessica Pegula as the nation’s top player. Despite Gauff’s stellar start to 2025 with a United Cup triumph, her momentum waned following early exits in Dubai, Doha, and the Sunshine Double. Meanwhile, Pegula quietly surged, reaching her first Miami Open final and closing the rankings gap to just 267 points.
Why Pegula Gets the Nod
The bold take comes from legendary coach Rick Macci, who helped shape the careers of Serena and Venus Williams. Macci took to social media to praise Pegula’s tactical intelligence, dubbing her the “American Master” and “Buffalo Blaster.”
“Her mind and strokes are like granite… Her understanding of the court gives others trouble.”
While Gauff’s explosive athleticism makes headlines, Macci argues Pegula’s consistency and doubles prowess (she’s been ranked No. 1 in doubles) solidify her as the true top American.
The numbers back his claim. Pegula, 31, has significantly fewer ranking points to defend this clay season—1,203 fewer than Gauff—giving her a strong chance to surpass the 20-year-old phenom. Her Miami Open final run, halted only by world No. 1 Aryna Sabalenka, showcased her ability to outthink opponents, a stark contrast to Gauff’s recent struggles with unforced errors and tactical rigidity.
Gauff’s Stumble vs. Pegula’s Resurgence
Gauff’s 2025 campaign has been a tale of two halves. After opening the year with nine straight wins, her season derailed with a quarterfinal loss in Melbourne and unexpected first-round exits in the Middle East. Though she showed glimpses of form in Indian Wells and Miami, her performances lacked the dominance she displayed in late 2024.
Meanwhile, Pegula turned setbacks into opportunities. Having missed much of 2024’s clay season due to injury, she now plays with both confidence and a point to prove.
What Defines Greatness?
Macci’s take isn’t just about rankings—it’s a referendum on what truly defines a nation’s top player. Gauff’s marketability and raw talent make her the face of American tennis, but Pegula’s disciplined, methodical approach is quietly shaping a legacy of its own.
While Gauff downplays the importance of being America’s No. 1, Pegula’s steady rise forces an important question: In a sport enamored with youth, does experience still reign supreme?
As the clay season unfolds, one thing is certain—the battle for America’s top spot has never been more compelling.
